McLeod Hospital in Florence, South Carolina recently
webcast a laparoscopic supracervical hysterectomy live on the internet. According to
this BBC article, such live webcasts are becoming increasingly common in the US as hospitals there try to gain a competitive edge by showcasing their best surgeons and the latest techniques.
I agree the operating theatre should not be the sole preserve of the medical profession and patients should be informed and educated about the procedures they undertake. However, the overt commercialism of these webcasts is disturbing.
They have marketing executives from equipment manufacturers hanging corporate logos on the walls of the operating theatre. I find such commercial exploitation morally objectionable.
While Dr David Chapman, the gynaecologist who performed the above procedure, says he does benefit directly from any of these companies, allowing these endorsements will only blur the line between commercial interest and professional responsibility.
This is another example of excessive commercialisation of healthcare provision in the US. Having a system dominated by large private corporations means healthcare providers end up catering to the needs of Big Business, not the needs of their patients. The US is the only developed nation in the world that does not guarantee affordable access to healthcare for all its citizens; those who cannot afford health insurance are left marginalised and dependent on basic emergency care.
I am personally in favour of a more socialist system of healthcare such as in the UK and to a lesser extent in Singapore. Healthcare should be fully or partially funded by the state, and supplemented by private practitioners.
In a way, the commercial nature of US healthcare is anathema to the spirit of the NHS. Granted waiting times are longer in a public healthcare system but here, good quality healthcare is made available to all, even those who can least afford it.
BBC News: Surgery goes live on the netMcLeod Health: Replay of Laparoscopic Supracervical HysterectomyRead about
healthcare in the US and
publicly funded medicine.